Explaining Short Job Stints and Employment Gaps

August 9, 2010 at 12:01 am 29 comments

There are many criteria that recruiters and HR professionals use to eliminate job applicants after screening their résumés. Recently I posted an article here on that topic [“The Brutal Truth on How Résumés Get Eliminated.”] That blog article became one of the most widely read postings on Recruiter Musings. Obviously, I touched a nerve there!

One of the potential problem areas I wrote about is job turnover. If your résumé’s job history shows too many short stints over a limited time period, the person screening it can read it as a negative: you might be a job-hopping flight risk … you seemingly can’t hold down a job … perhaps you don’t get along with others well … there may have been performance issues that got you fired – the imagination creates all kinds of possible scenarios! Likewise, significant unexplained gaps between jobs can be red flags that will get you eliminated. And finally, if you are not currently working and you’ve been out of work for a long time … well, I don’t have to tell you how awkward it is when someone asks you: “So, what have you been doing since you left your last job?” I thought it might be helpful to suggest some strategies that can be used to overcome those issues.

Too Much Job Turnover

There may be perfectly valid reasons for having a lot of jobs within a short period. I would advise briefly listing the reasons for those short job stints right next to the dates on your résumé to avoid this obvious red flag. The idea here is to be pro-active, and answer their questions about why you left each job before those questions are even asked. It’s a simple thing, and yet very few people do it. You don’t need to go into long-winded or detailed explanations. All you need is a brief phrase, in parenthesis, following the dates of each short-lived position. For example: “Laid Off Due To Economic Circumstances” … or “Position Was Eliminated” … or “Company Went Out of Business,” etc. What this does is provide the screener with a perfectly valid explanation for the short stint, and eliminates the possibility that they will imagine something much worse – i.e., that you were fired for cause, poor performance, etc. (Of course, if you actually were fired for cause … well, that’s another story!)

Unexplained Gaps Between Jobs

Unlike a job application, a résumé is not a legal document and there is no requirement that it must contain a complete history of everything you’ve ever done. It should be truthful … but it’s up to you to decide what to include or not include. Here’s a suggestion: the dates listed next to each job do not have to include the months – instead, you can show them as a range of years. That can often avoid the red flag of seeing brief periods of unemployment between jobs. Likewise, if there are jobs in your work history (especially if they were short-lived) that were unrelated to your main industry or niche … there’s no reason you can’t leave those off the résumé. You only need to feature your most relevant positions – and usually only go back about 10 years. Many people take positions outside of their industry while between jobs as a temporary way of maintaining an income until they find something in their field. Others have jobs earlier in their chronology that are also outside of their current target industry. Listing those “side-trips” can sometimes be distracting to a screener who is only focused on looking for experience in one particular field.

The one caution I’ll add here, is that sooner or later almost every company will have you fill out an official job application form. Unlike your résumé, that application is actually a legal document that you must sign … so don’t leave anything off of that one. Be sure every job, employment date, salary, and educational degree that you list is accurate. It’s better to leave something blank, than to guess or make something up. Background checks will inevitably uncover incorrect information … and inconsistent or false information on an application will look like you’ve intentionally lied. That almost always results in the applicant being eliminated. I’ve seen job offers withdrawn for things like candidates listing the wrong dates of employment or school graduations, exaggerating salary histories, fabricating educational degrees, etc. Just tell the truth!

Currently Not Working

Believe it or not, there actually are companies out there who have made it known that they won’t consider hiring unemployed candidates!  I know – it sounds outrageous … and that’s a topic for another blog. [See “'Unemployed Need Not Apply' - Working Around This Scary Message.”] Nevertheless, it’s obviously in any job-seeker’s best interest to not appear to be unemployed. So, if it’s been a long while since you left your last full-time job, how do you handle that? Different people handle this issue different ways on their résumés. Here are three common solutions:

Volunteer Work:  Many job-seekers turn to volunteer work as a way of staying busy and feeling useful while unemployed. Besides the obvious personal benefits that come from the act of giving of yourself, sharing your time, helping others and upping your “karma” score, volunteering can often get your “foot in the door” with a company that might potentially hire you in the future. Showing people what you can do, how well you can do it, and demonstrating your exceptional work ethic – even if it’s not in a paid position – can bring you to the attention of professionals who notice such things, and reward them when opportunities open up. If you are volunteering somewhere, then list that volunteer position on your resume as your current position. However, do NOT use the term “volunteer!” Simply list the organization and your title or role, describe your function, relevant skills used, and any accomplishments there just as you would with any of your other jobs. Let the fact that you are not being paid wait for an interview, where you should then disclose it.

Consulting (Contract) Work:  Depending on your field, many job-seekers choose to take temporary assignments, contract work, or other “1099″ (non-employee) jobs. People who engage is this type of work often refer to themselves as “consultants.” Very often, those contract jobs have the possibility of turning into full-time positions. Again, list those temporary “consulting” positions on your resume … and highlight the relevant skills you used, and any accomplishments achieved at those temporary assignments. If your period of “consulting” was not long-term or consistent, list it as one long job period (from the last full-time job till the present) and under that “Consulting” heading list some individual assignments without specifying dates. Again, leave the exact details of when and for how long you actually worked at each assignment for either an interview or an official job application. The goal here is to look like you’ve been keeping busy and working in your field.

Self-Employment:  These days, more and more job-seekers are turning to starting their own businesses. There’s even a media-coined term for this phenomenon: “Entrepreneur by Necessity.” If you are in that category – by all means list it on your resume as your current occupation. Whether or not you’ve actually earned any income from your company or had any actual success in your venture, listing a self-owned company on your resume is much better than having a large gap of current unemployment without any explanation. And, of course, it’s the perfect answer to that question: “So, what have you been doing since you left your last job?”

Entry filed under: Advice for Job Seekers. Tags: , .

The Floor is Now Open for Questions … “Unemployed Need Not Apply” – Working Around This Scary Message

29 Comments Add your own

  • 1. Christine Francois  |  August 9, 2010 at 12:14 pm

    Excellent advice Michael and the videos made me laugh…great way to start ANY day!

    Reply
  • 2. Karin Moss  |  August 9, 2010 at 1:52 pm

    Hello, Michael -
    I just wanted to tell you how much I enjoy your blog. Not only is it evident that you are a “mensch” but the information you provide is extremely valuable.

    Thanks for your insights!

    Karin Moss

    Reply
  • 3. Nancy Patterson  |  August 9, 2010 at 2:11 pm

    A quick comment on this excellent subject…

    I am one of those applicants who has gaps and short employment history. It’s not what I planned, it just turned out that way. During my last 6-month search, I was often asked why was I still available. I would politely smile and say:

    When the right fit, location, and compensation all line up, I’m looking forward to accepting that offer. It just has not happened yet.

    For me, that answer worked. I found I was more receptive to a company that was more interested in what I could do for them today and moving forward vs where I had been. You cannot change history. Just learn to skip around it confidently.

    Going into any interview I wanted to know if my skills could fix their problem, not get me a job.

    Reply
    • 4. Pooja Mishra  |  September 27, 2010 at 11:35 pm

      Hey Nancy,

      I agree with your point. I believe that employer should focus on present that what value i can add to their business rather than focusing on past and making the judgments without knowing the reasons. They can also confirm through reference check the reasons for a candidate’s leaving the job.

      Thanks for posting.
      Best

      Pooja

      Reply
  • 5. Pegg Milroy  |  August 9, 2010 at 7:14 pm

    Hi Michael,

    Thanks for the answer to resume employment gaps-I especially like that your opinion of not using the word “Volunteer” matches mine. You can say it in the interview- but do not put it in writing in the resume.

    Although I know I am guilty of it also- one of the best ways to shoot yourself in the foot in job seeking is TMI (Too Much Information.)

    You have one of the best blogs out there- proud to be a fellow Clevelander.

    Pegg Milroy

    Reply
  • 6. TK  |  August 11, 2010 at 8:09 am

    What about the opposite side of the fence. If you have been with the same employer for 10 – 15 years, is that a positive or negative?

    Reply
    • 7. Michael Spiro  |  August 11, 2010 at 8:26 am

      TK:
      I don’t think a 10-15 year job stint is necessarily either a negative or a positive. It all depends on how one looks at it. There is certainly something to be said for job stability and employee loyalty. The more important issue would be whether or not you had increasing responsibilities within that one long job time span … and if you did – to show that on your résumé. And, of course, how much your particular skills are in demand in today’s market.
      - Michael

      Reply
  • 8. David P  |  August 11, 2010 at 9:17 am

    With today’s economy and so many people consulting, is this as much of an issue as in previous decades? Most companies have a strict time limit on consultants thereby forcing a job change every 9-24 months depending on the length of the contract. There are also numerous cases where someone obtains permanent employment only to have the company go through a restructuring or actually go under shortly thereafter. In my opinion, as long as you are not truly job hopping, being upfront in a job interview is the way to go. A hiring manager would have to be ignorant of the current job market to not take these conditions into account when reviewing a resume or a candidate.

    My two cents.

    Reply
    • 9. Michael Spiro  |  August 11, 2010 at 9:28 am

      David:
      If someone is “consulting” (1099 contract jobs) then this is a non-issue. Those types of jobs are, by definition, temporary assignments that do not require further explanation. It’s when a person has a series of short-lived permanent positions that the red flags go up. Yes, with today’s economy there are many valid explanations for short stints. I’m simply suggesting that it’s better to provide those explanations on the resume to avoid being eliminated during the initial screening stage. “Being up front in a job interview” is all fine and good … but that only works if you get past the initial review and get invited to actually have an interview!
      - Michael

      Reply
      • 10. Al  |  August 15, 2010 at 2:20 pm

        This is an interesting discussion and you both make excellent points. As a 20-year consultant, I think it is still important how it is presented regardless of the time. Yes I have had many project for many clients over the years but all of which was operated under a few major firms (ie, E&Y, Fujitsu, IBM), thus technically not much change at all. I think it is reasonable for a consultant to average 2-years at a position is ideal, which is longer than the average cio term. the fact is most projects are 3-6 months vs those that are 12-18 months. So yes, there are dangers to showing too many short term jobs, for all the reasons previously stated, but also issues with those that have been with a single firm for 15 – 18 – 20 – 25+ years, as they may have trouble adapting to a new enviornment, organization, corp culture, etc.. The net net is that there needs to be a balance and how you spin it, but always be truthful to prospective employers, clients and most importantly yourself…

  • 11. Mike Perry  |  August 12, 2010 at 9:42 am

    Michael –

    Just started reading your blog and love it!

    I’ve been a hiring manager for over 30 years, and do a lot of pro-bono job search coaching along with presentations at job seekers groups. Your comments and suggestions really “hit the mark” and address very well many of the questions and concerns I continue to hear from job seekers.

    The people who put the effort into incorporating your ideas into their job search strategies will find it much easier to differentiate themselves from the dozens or hundreds of other candidates seeking the same position.

    Thank you..!!

    Reply
  • 12. shebamarx  |  August 12, 2010 at 7:34 pm

    So, what do you think is a short stint? Is it 2 years? One year?

    Reply
    • 13. Michael Spiro  |  August 12, 2010 at 10:09 pm

      That’s a very good question … and I don’t have an exact answer. I think it depends somewhat on how many jobs you’ve had over a period of time. For example, 5-10 jobs over a four or five year period (and I’ve seen that scenario many times) seems like a red flag. On the other hand, a single short job (one-year or less) sandwiched in between two multi-year stints is less problematic, and probably easier to explain. There is no hard and fast rule.

      Reply
  • 14. Nicola James  |  August 17, 2010 at 5:31 pm

    Good stuff, Michael, and spot on. Very relevant and as another recruiter, I heartily agree with your points.

    Reply
  • 15. Sarah  |  August 18, 2010 at 6:34 pm

    Michael – saw your comment on LinkedIn (and looked back at some of your “musings”) and found it very helpful. I worked with the same company for about 8 years and have now been unemployed for over a year (only recently seeking employment). One of my biggest fears is explaining that gaping hole on my resume. I recently signed up for 2 volunteer positions and I’m glad to see that as one of your suggestions for people who are unemployed. It’s nice to know I’m doing something right!

    Reply
  • 16. Pooja Mishra  |  September 27, 2010 at 11:31 pm

    Hi Michael,

    Just loved your blog. I have a question.

    I have done my MBA-HR in 2009 and as you know it was a recession year so though i got a job but not what i wanted. So, i left my first job after working for 11 months and joined an HR consultancy. I loved this job but i had to leave again b’coz of some family issues i had to relocate to other city where they dont have any office. Here, i worked for 4 months. Now, i am unemployed and looking for a job and finding it very tough to get a call for an interview.

    As you said, we can write the reasons briefly in the resume itself, but would employers accept the fact that in the initial year of one’s career somebody can leave job for family issues?

    Would it be a good idea to write in my resume?

    Pooja.

    Reply
    • 17. Michael Spiro  |  September 28, 2010 at 5:48 pm

      Pooja:

      That’s a tough one. I guess it depends on the nature of the “family issues” you mentioned. Simply saying “left due to family relocation” might be sufficient. Just be prepared to explain it further when asked.

      Michael

      Reply
  • 18. John Golby  |  August 26, 2011 at 8:44 am

    As an illustrator and having worked in the Social Services I too have gaps in my employment but I just don’t see what the gaps have to do with anyone else.I recently signed with an agency who wanted to know what I was doing for three months in 2006 – no wonder there is unemployment and the fact that I was in Hong Kong is my own business, as long as my CRB is in the clear that should be good enough.

    Reply
    • 19. Michael Spiro  |  August 26, 2011 at 11:03 am

      John:
      I agree that a 3-month gap between jobs is very insignificant — and any recruiter who focuses on such a short period of time is probably very inexperienced. On the other hand, it would be naive to assume that longer gaps between jobs will not be a problem for you as a job-seeker. You many not think they are a important … but as I said in my blog article, significant unexplained gaps absolutely do raise red flags for recruiters, HR professionals and company decision-makers. Without reasonable explanations, people often assume very negative things about why you were out of work for so long, and may consider you a hiring risk. Like it or not, fair or unfair … that’s just the way it works. You might be passed over for job opportunities because of such gaps without ever knowing why. And as to your trip to Hong Kong — I’m not sure what that’s all about, but if it was a personal trip unrelated to your job history, then it should not be on your resume at all — and should certainly not be a topic of discussion with a recruiter. Having your CRB (Criminal Record Bureau, right?) be “in the clear” is an unrelated issue, and has nothing do to with any employment gaps on your resume.
      -Michael

      Reply
  • 20. Nancy P  |  August 26, 2011 at 11:07 am

    I have had many ‘gaps’ in my employment history. During an interview, I address the gaps quickly and work to bring the conversation to my strengths and what I can do for the employer today. If I have yet to find the perfect role and there is a lengthy timeframe my standard answer is: when the location, finances, and fit line up, I’m ready to accept an offer. One cannot erase the past and if an employer is really all that concerned about a gap, they’re not the best fit for me. Too many rules ;)

    Reply
  • 21. Robert  |  March 17, 2012 at 1:16 pm

    I, for the first time in my life, have been employed with two different companies in a period of 14 months- 1 job for eight months and was recruited for a job I accepted for only six months-these certainly define a short stint of employment I would imagine.

    If this is considered a red flag, does a previous history of longer employment over shadow these?

    If during a short stint there are considerable accomplishments that are shown on the resume does this also help lessen the impact?

    Reply
    • 22. Michael Spiro  |  March 19, 2012 at 2:38 pm

      Robert:
      Showing a prior history of long employment, and also listing significant accomplishments are both good things that may or may not counter-balance the potential negative impact of two short back-to-back job stints that follow. The more important question you need to address (not mentioned at all in your comment to me) is WHY you left each of those two jobs after such short periods. Deciding to leave a job simply because you found a better opportunity after only 8 months could be seen as a red flag to some. (What’s to prevent you from leaving your next job quickly if a better offer comes along?) And then, why did that second job last for only 6 months? Did you quit? Were you let go for cause? Was it an unexpected lay-off? The explanations you provide are key to how those short stints will be perceived by anyone reviewing your job history. No one wants to hire someone who might be a flight risk.
      -Michael

      Reply
      • 23. Robbie  |  March 19, 2012 at 7:03 pm

        Understood.

        The explanation simply is for the eight month stint is the company misrepresented the area-geographically disadvantaged & insufficient housing, crime, etc.I was expected to relo (at my expense) however, during the time my family was trying to sell our home (I had an apartment) I realized I could not move them to this place.

        The six month term was one in which I’ll forever hang my head in embarrassment-I violated a company policy (A minor one-but none the less) and was released. Their feet were held to the fire on this one as there was an employee who was making a big deal of why a member of mgmt was not being held accountable-regardless I have to own my mistake.

        I’ve enjoyed a successful career w/out blemish and full of accomplishments, however, this last job is (with a company for which I have great respect) will personally forever haunt me.

        The glimmer is that I will get great recommendations from the company officers, which I hope will minimize the damage…

        Thanks

  • 24. Sarah  |  April 25, 2012 at 12:37 pm

    I have a question.
    I’m on the younger end of the job hunting spectrum. Most of my jobs have been short tenure, but explainable (I left one to relocate to the city where my fiance lived, one was a summer contract position). One however, I left because the job was not at all what I expected and I was not equipped to handle the working environment, or what I felt like was a lack of training and support.
    While the first two are explainable, I’m not sure how to explain the last (and most recent) one.
    If it helps, I also do freelance work and have since 2009. (I have recommendations from past clients).
    How do I address this on my resume?
    Thank you!

    Reply
    • 25. Michael Spiro  |  April 28, 2012 at 9:49 am

      Sarah:
      That’s a tough one. I would not try to explain that last one on your résumé. Depending on how you portray your “freelance work” section, you may not have to even list that last job at all — especially if it was a short stint. Freelance work (much like “consulting”) can serve as an umbrella on your resume to cover a long period of time during which you may have done work for multiple clients. Save your explanation of why your last job was a bad fit for an interview. Trying to explain it on your résumé the way you did in your question will raise too many red flags.
      Michael

      Reply
  • 26. John  |  May 1, 2012 at 8:58 pm

    Great post, Michael.

    I have a question for you. I “rolled” a short team employment, 6 months, into my next long team job, 6 years and 8 months. So, in fact, I only worked at my present job for 6 years and 2 months. But my resume stated month/year. How should I address this issue on my resume?

    Thanks

    Reply
    • 27. Michael Spiro  |  May 2, 2012 at 2:21 pm

      John:
      I don’t really understand what you are asking. Do you want to know if it’s OK to combine the short stint with the longer job? (Sometimes that makes sense — for example, if it’s a contract job that falls under the umbrella of a consulting period of work experience, if it’s a different position at the same company as the job that you are combining it with, etc.) How should you “address this issue” on your resume? I’m not sure what that even means. If you are asking me to tell you how to explain the short stint — I have no idea! Only you know the answer as why you left that job after only 6 months. Oh, and why not simply change the format of your entire resume to using only years and not months at all. Would that solve your problem?
      -Michael

      Reply
      • 28. John  |  May 2, 2012 at 4:01 pm

        Sorry about the confusion.

        Say I worked at company A from Jan to Apri in 2005. Then I started at B from May 2005 until now. So officially I work at B for 7 years. However, I put down 7 years and 4 months on my resume for company B under the advice from my wife.

        So, the question is how do I explain the “gap” when an employment verification is done and if my future employer finds the gap.

        Thanks

      • 29. Michael Spiro  |  May 2, 2012 at 5:53 pm

        You should re-read the two paragraphs in the blog above under the heading: “Unexplained Gaps Between Jobs.” As I explained there, a resume is not a legal document, and does not have to list EVERYTHING you’ve done. Just list years, and not months. Don’t include the 4-month job at all if it was not significant. (Your wife’s advice was well-intended, but wrong — you should not combine unrelated jobs or change employment dates.) On the other hand, filling out a formal job application is another story. That must include everything, and it must be accurate — including the actual start and end dates of each and every job you’ve had. A background check will, indeed, include employment verification which must match that application you fill out. Discrepancies between your application and your actual job history will kill your chances of getting hired. The only “gap” you should have to explain is if you had an extended period of unemployment.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed


Michael Spiro

About the Author:

Michael Spiro has been a 3rd-Party Recruiter and Account Executive for over 13 years. He is currently the Director of Talent Solutions at Patina Solutions, a unique professional services firm that deploys senior-level professionals with at least 25 or more years of experience on a flexible contract/consulting basis to help companies in multiple industries. He is also the President of Midas Recruiting, a Sales Head-Hunting firm. Prior to that, he worked for two of the largest search firms in North America. Before his career in the staffing industry, Michael was a manager in a large non-profit organization. And in a former life, Michael was active in the entertainment industry, with extensive road-warrior experience as a touring performer (singer-songwriter / guitarist / comedian) and as a recording artist, producer and booking agent.  [More...]

Recent Posts:

Previous Posts:

►  Comic Relief: Job-Seeking
      Humor - Volume 3

------------------------------------------
►  The Résumé Test & Checklist:
      Does Yours Pass?

------------------------------------------
►  The "T" Cover Letter -
      The Only Type Worth Sending

------------------------------------------
►  The Brutal Truth on how
      Résumés Get Eliminated

------------------------------------------
►  Comic Relief: Job-Seeking
      Humor - Volume 2

------------------------------------------
►  Age Discrimination: Exposing
      Inconvenient Truths

------------------------------------------
►  The Double-Whammy of
      Rejection and Isolation

------------------------------------------
►  Is Your “Elevator Pitch” Taking
      You UP or DOWN?

------------------------------------------
►  Comic Relief: Job-Seeking
      Humor - Volume 1

------------------------------------------
►  Warning: That Rant You
      Posted Just Went Viral!

------------------------------------------
►  Using Social Media to Enhance
      Job-Searching

------------------------------------------
►  Avoiding the “Black Hole
      of HR”

------------------------------------------
►  “In Transition” and Other
      Awkward Euphemisms

------------------------------------------
►  Getting Un-Stuck from
      your Rut!

------------------------------------------
►  Recipe for a Well-Balanced
      Job Search

------------------------------------------
►  Face-to-Face Interviews:
      Secrets, Tips and Tricks

------------------------------------------
►  Counteroffers: Just Say No!
------------------------------------------
►  The Proper Way to Quit a Job
------------------------------------------
►  The Real Truth About Working
      with Recruiters

------------------------------------------
►  Phone Interviews:
      Secrets, Tricks and Tips

------------------------------------------
►  The Golden Rule: Never Burn
      Bridges

------------------------------------------
►  Candidates Gone Wild:
      Recruiter Horror Stories

------------------------------------------
►  Following-Up: An Essential
      Key to Success

------------------------------------------
►  Nuggets: A Secret Interviewing
      Technique

------------------------------------------
►  New Year’s Resolutions for
      Unemployed Job-Seekers

------------------------------------------
►  How to Network: A Step-by-
      Step Guide for Job-Searching

------------------------------------------
►  Top 10 Most Helpful Things for
      Job-Seekers

------------------------------------------
►  Top 10 Most Annoying Things
      for Job-Seekers

------------------------------------------
►  Age Discrimination: Secret
      Conversations Revealed!

------------------------------------------
►  The Art of Giving: The Key to
      Effective Networking

------------------------------------------
►  Targeted Networking: How to
      Effectively Reach Out

------------------------------------------
►  Why Job Hunting is a
      Consultative Sales Position

------------------------------------------
►  The Power of a Positive
      Attitude

------------------------------------------
►  Looking for Networking in
      All the Wrong Places

------------------------------------------
►  Answering the Dreaded Salary
      Question

Share This Blog:

Click the button below to share “Recruiter Musings” on any of over 250 social media sites:

Share this blog with any of your favorite Social Networks, email or bookmark it.

Enter your email address below to subscribe to “Recruiter Musings” and receive notifications of new blog posts by email.

Join 249 other followers

Job Opportunities:

Click below to see job opportunities listed through the author’s company, Midas Recruiting:

Register with Patina:

If you are a professional with 25 or more years of work experience, click below and register with Patina Solutions to be considered for their Portfolio of Talent:

Direct Connection:

Blog Visitor Count:

  • 160,664 hits

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 249 other followers